This set of pages is dedicated to exploring the violation and manipulation of the CD Standard to hide audio tracks within regular audio CDs or otherwise cause CDs to act in a way not intended by the creators of the audio CD standard.
Some simple CD standard background information Although the audio CD standard is fairly rigid, many artists and their engineers have exploited parts of the standard where there are no particular limits. Before getting to the details of these CD oddities, it is best to know some basic information about how CD audio tracks are constructed and handled by both stand-alone CD players and PC applications. The actual structure of a CD track is really quite complicated and this is not an attempt to list and explain all of the intricacies of the elements that a CD track contains. Ken Pohlmann's excellent The Compact Disc Handbook has a completely detailed description of a CD track and I encourage you to try and find this book if you are interested . For my purposes, I'll define CD tracks as consisting of digital data containing two index points which determine where tracks begin and/or end. Although one can have up to 99 indexed locations within a track, the two most often used indexes are Index 00 and Index 01. These two indexes are present on all audio CD tracks. Index 00 precedes the audio portion of the track and is often referred to as a pregap or pause with a countdown to the lead-out area (Index 01). Index 01 is where the audio portion of the track starts. The general behaviour of CD players has the player detecting indexes via the disc's table of contents in the lead-in area (the innermost band of a disc) and P and Q channel data contained in every frame. A frame is the smallest recognizable section of a disc. All of this data allows CD player manufacturers to perform certain actions such as identifying separations between tracks, resetting a time display to 00:00 or actually playing audio. PC applications also handle CD audio tracks in the same basic way. Generally, there is a two second gap between songs on a CD. Live CDs and other tracks that segue into one another are examples of where this is not necessarily true. This is mentioned here as the CD standard requires that the very first track (Track 1) have an Index 00 starting a minimum of two seconds before Index 01 (the start of audio on Track 1). Tracks 2 through 99 don't have this requirement and usually have varying Index 00 and Index 01 locations although the two second pregap is widely used. 99 tracks is the maximum number of tracks allowed on a CD. Manipulation of the space and data between Index 00 and Index 01 comprises the most interesting of CD oddities contained on these pages. Other oddities covered on these pages include multiple tracks within one track and other intentional deviations from the CD standard which may or may not cause certain amounts of havoc on different stand-alone and PC application players.
Index 00 Manipulation (click here for the list of "Index 00" CDs) One of the most interesting places that the CD standard can be manipulated is with the placement of Index 00 and the data between Index 00 and Index 01. There are no rules that say Index 00 has to be any minimum length with the exception of Track 1. Manipulating Index 00 usually involves putting audio (data) into the space between Index 00 and Index 01. This results in both semi- and fully hidden tracks within and between normal audio tracks. This works in two distinct ways depending on the Track number in which the data is placed. Accessing the hidden track(s) also depends on this: Index 00 data on Track 01 (fully hidden)
Index 00 data on Tracks 2 through 99 (semi hidden) For example, if Track 6 of a CD has Index 00 with audio data starting some amount of time before Index 01 then it can be accessed by playing Track 5 (the previous track) and Track 6 back-to-back. As with the Track 1 case, you can see the effects of this on the time display of the stand-alone CD player:
Note: If one uses "Shuffle mode" on the stand-alone CD player this type of "hidden" track will never play because "shuffle" forces the player to treat each track as a separate entity and start each track at Index 01. PC Application behaviour on Track 1
Multiple track(s) within a track (click here for the list of "Multiple tracks within a track" CDs) The least interesting but no less important oddity case is where multiple tracks are added to one whole track. The music on tracks like this are usually separated by some amount of silence. This is most often done on the final track of a CD as a long stretch of silence in the middle of a CD would be odd. Using the final track gives the illusion of the CD being finished and then offering the user a surprise for being diligent or just leaving the CD playing in the player. There are a number of cases listed on this page which use Track 13 to hide this type of track--although anything relating to triskadecaphobia (the fear of the number "13") or some other numerical superstition causing or prompting this is purely speculation...
Violations of the CD standard (click here for the list of these CDs) There is at least one CD which violate the part of the CD standard that defines the minimum length of a track which is 4 seconds. The Nine Inch Nails CD called "Broken" features 92 1-second tracks (tracks 7 through 97). This causes varied effects on certain stand-alone CD players from skipping and track location problems. Another CD with the same attributes but does not violate the standard is The Marilyn Manson CD titled "Antichrist Superstar". It also has a large collection of short silent tracks and is included in this list. Those tracks are all 4 seconds long, however, and thus do not deviate from the CD standard. There is also a Dramarama CD called "Vinyl" which may violate this standard but I have not been able to purchase it to check it out. The final oddity in this category is a two-CD set called "Swarm Of Drones" where CD #2 starts at Track 11 (CD #1 ends at Track 10). This may cause problems but none have been discovered so far.
How to contribute your CD oddity data I am always interested in hearing about CDs which are not already listed on the CD oddities listing pages (see the links attached to each section above). Send your CD oddity discoveries to wjc@turbine.com. I will, at my convenience, research the CD you send me information about and list it here if it has hidden tracks. Please try to provide as much information as possible and include your name and email address and whether or not you want me to credit you for your submission. Note: Please don't send me any listings about specially die-cut CDs, business -card CDs or other such items UNLESS they have hidden tracks or somehow deviate from the audio CD standard.
Credits Many thanks go to Andy McFadden who is very knowledgeable in the ways of all things CD. Visit his CD-FAQ--it is filled with invaluable CD and CD-related information. (By the way, Andy has been a colleague and friend of mine for a few years (and a few start-up companies) and is an all-around cool guy...) |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Last modified: Friday October 17 2008 Copyright © 2003 Turbine Industries |
||
|
|
||
| No. [an error occurred while processing this directive] |